You are here

Головна » ECONOMICS AND MANAGEMENT APC №2 2024

The ukrainian economic school of the end of the 19th beginning of the XX century: formation and development

The article develops the positions and ideas of authors on the formation of the national architectural science of economic science and politics. On the basis of the analysis of Ukrainian economic literature 19- 20 years of the twentieth century. grounded the provisions on the emergence and institutionalization of the Ukrainian economic school as a scientific problem, methods of its solution, organization and sustainable reproduction of the corresponding co-authorship of scientists-representatives of the school. The main reasons and factors of growth of scientific interest in these issues in modern world and national literature are revealed. The disclosure of issues of the formation  and development of the Ukrainian economic school is based on the author's developed propositions in three aspects: on periodization, theoretical directions and unity of components of economic science. Theoretical identification of the concepts: "scientific school" and "Ukrainian economic school" were implemented on the basis of application of scientific-science criteria. The essence, key theories and the circle of representatives of the Ukrainian economic school, its characteristic features, general and special research of phenomena and processes, connection with economic policy are found out. The revealed epistemological foundations and one-sidedness of modern concepts of development of the Ukrainian economic science of the 19th and early 20th centuries. as "adaptive-catchup" and "methodologically-conflict". In contrast, they have substantiated the concepts of "breakthrough», «synthetic" development of the Ukrainian economic school. The role and importance of the scientific work of the representatives of the Ukrainian economic school in the conduct of economic policies, established morality in scientific research and life activity are highlighted.
It was shown that on the basis of the critical analysis of the achievements of the general scientific, economic world, representatives of Ukrainian schools, including economic ones, supplemented their latest ideas and concepts, considering the need to take into account the historical and social aspects of the development of the economy, traditions an mental features of society. It was proved that it was precisely our predecessors who, by their critical review of the initial provisions of classical political economy and Marxism, not only led to an intensive process of changing the whole system of development of Ukrainian economic thought at the end of the 19th to the beginning of the 20th century, but also laid the foundations for the formation of the social foundations of economic research, economic methodology of psychological moments and the birth of the institutional foundations of economic analysis, which is already at the turn of the XIX - XX centuries. has brought domestic economic thought closer to the world level. Kyiv economic schools were at the forefront of economic research of the period, with significant scientific results, the proof of which werethe works of M. Bunge, E. Slutsky, O. Bilimovich, who had a powerful influence not only on Ukrainian but also on the world economic science.
Key words: scientific school, Ukrainian economic school, national architectonics in science, marketeconomy, economic policy, synthesis of theories and directions, institutionalism.

 

Yukhymenko P https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0677-1872


1. Barnett, Vincent (2005). History of Russian Economic Thought (Routledge History of Economic Thought). Barnett Vincent. London : Routledge. 256. URL. : http://ua.bookfi.org/book/1135216.
2. Zvainert, Y. (2007). Historia rerum oeconomicarum in Russia, 1805-1905 [History of economicthought in Russia, 1805-1905;]; trans. cum German L. I. Tsedilyna; sub scientia ed. V. S. Autonomia. M.: Izd. Domus Civitatis Universitatis Superioris Educationis, 411.
3. Leonenko, P. M. (2004) Rationes methodologicae historiae Ucrainae cogitationis oeconomicae (saecula XIX-XX) [Methodological aspects of the history of Ukrainian economic thought (XIX-XX centuries)]: monographum. K.: IAE UAAS, 434 p.
4. Nebrat, V. V. (2013). Evolutio theoriae oeconomicae publicae in Ucraina: monograph [Evolution of the theory of public finance in Ukraine: monograph.]. NAS of Ucraina, Institute of Oeconomica. Et praedixit K.: 584 p.
5. Golubka, S. M. (2013). Institutionalization oeconomiae oeconomicae Ucrainae (retrospectivae historicae) [Institutionalization of the financial economy of Ukraine (historical retrospective)]. [Text]: [monographum]. Sumptibus. educationem et scientiam institutione «Acad. rebus oeconomicis usu». Kyiv: DNNU« Acad. rebus oeconomicis ed.. 452 p.
6. Gorkyna, L. P. (1994). Mykhailo Ivanovich Tugan-Baranovsky — excogitator, physicus, civis: Prooemium. Tugan-Baranovsky M. I. Oeconomia politica: Cursus popularis [Mykhailo Ivanovich Tugan-Baranovsky — thinker, scientist, citizen: Foreword // Tugan-Baranovsky M. I. Political economy: A popular course.]. K.: Scientia. dumka, 281 p.
7. Feshchenko, V. M. (2003). Investigatio quaestionum de formatione et progressu oeconomiae mercatus in scriptis oeconomistae Ucrainae mediae saeculi XIX et XX primi [A study of the problems of the formation and development of the market economy in the writings of Ukrainian economists of the sec49 econommeneg.btsau.edu.ua Економіка та управління АПК, 2024, № 2 ond half of the 19th and early 20th centuries]. K.: KNEU, 187 p.
8. Yukhymenko, P. I., Lyovochkin, S. V., Fedosov, V. M., Yuriy, S. I. (2010). Sententia oeconomica Ucrainae [Financial opinion of Ukraine.]. Monograph; scientiarum ed. V. M. Fedosova K.: Condor. In 3 vols. 687 p.
9. Krysovatyy, A., Fedosov, V., Yuriy, S., Yukhymenko, P. (2016). Financial Thought of Ukraine: Genesis and Evolution: in two volumes. Volume 1.Monoghaph. Berlin, 604 p.; Volume 2. Encyclopedia. Berlin, 512 р.
10. Shletser, H. A. (1805). Fundamenta oeconomiae publicae, seu scientiarum de divitiis nationalibus [Basic foundations of the state economy, or Sciences about national wealth]: in 2 ch. M., Part 1. 196 p.;1806
11. Shletser, H. A. (1806). Fundationes oeconomiae publicae, seu scientiarum opum nationalium [Foundations of the state economy, or Sciences of national wealth]: in 2 cap. Moscow, Part 1. 196 p.; Part 2. 366 p.
12. E. Lortikyan, L. (2004). Historia rerum oeconomicarum et oeconomicarum Ucrainae. Etiam vitae cursus eros [History of economics and economic thought of Ukraine. Evolution of the market economy]. Kh.: Konsum, 360 p.
13. Patlaevsky, I. I. (2010). Cursus iuris oeconomici [Course of financial law]: In lib..: cogitation nummaria de Ucraina. Bibliography / author-compilers: S. I. Yuriy, S. V. Lyovochkin, V. M. Fedosov,P. I. scientiarum Ed. Fedosova K.: Condor, In 3 vols. T. 3. Part 1.. P. 275-276.
14. Horlov, I. Y. (1845). Heoria de rebus oeconomicis. [Theory of finance.]. 2nd ed., ed. et multiplicamini St. Petersburg: Typ. I. Glazunova and Co.,
280 p.
15. Sobolev, M. N. (1919). Auxilia ad scholas cooperativas [Economic theory of cooperation.]: et cursus. Kh.: Soyuz, 196 p.
16. Stepanov, T. (1845). Notae de oeconomia politica [Notes on political economy.]. Kh.: University. Type., 1845. Part 1. 371 p.
17. Lebedev, V.A. (1889). Lex Financial [Financial Law.]. T. 1: Issue 1-3. 2nd ed., recognitum. S.-Pb.: Typo-lit. A.M. Wolf,. 962 p.
18. Sydorenko, G. D. (1888). Zhytomyr: Typogr. ac lithogr. heres [Outline of lectures on Russian financial law.]. S. Brodovych, 341 p.
19. Ilovaisky, S. I. (1904). Libellus de iure pecuniario [Textbook of financial law]. Odesa : Typ. Sokolovsky, 383 p.
20. Eeberg, K. T. (1913) Cursus scientiarum oeconomicarum [Course of financial science]; trans. cum German Petropoli: Typogr. P. Rosena, 604 p.
21. Vitte, S. Yu. (1992) Oeconomia nationalis et Friderici List [National economy and Friedrich List]. Quaestiones oeconomicae. N. 2. P. 140–160.
22. Bukharin, N. I. (1988). Oeconomia politica rentier. Theoria valoris lucri scholae Austriacae [Political economy of rentier. The theory of the value of profit of the Austrian school.]. M.: Orbita, 192 p.
23. Ozerov, I. (1904). Yanzhul Ivan Ivanovich [Yanzhul Ivan Ivanovich]: Dictionarium Encyclopedicum Brockhaus et Efron. St. Petersburg, T. 82. 668 p.
24. Yanzhul, I. I. (1874). Rerum Anglicarum experientia indirecta tributa. Excisa [Research experience of English indirect taxes. Excise.]. M.: Typogr. A.I. Mamontova and Co., 319 p.
25. Yanzhul I. I. (1895). Industriae syndicatae et uniones negotii productionis moderandae in Civitatibus Foederatis Americae Septentrionalis [Industrial syndicates and business unions for productionregulation in the United States of North America]. St. Petersburg, 459 p.
26. Baludyanskyi, M. [Mykhailo Andriyovych Baludyanskyi.] - V. Kn..: Lyovochkin S.V., Fedosov V.M., Yuriy S.I., Yukhymenko P.I. Sententiaoeconomica Ucrainae. Encyclopaedia; scientiarum  Ed. Fedosova K.: Condor, 2010. In 3 vols. T. 2. 2010. P. 52–64.
27. Kulisher, Y. [Kulisher Yosyp Mykhailovych.] V. kn..: Lyovochkin S.V., Fedosov V.M., Yuriy S.I., Yukhymenko P.I. Sententia oeconomica Ucrainae. Encyclopaedia; scientiarum Ed. Fedosova K.: Condor, 2010. In 3 vols.
28. Bogolepov, M. I. (1915). I. Kaufman (obituarium) [I. Kaufman (obituary)]. Praeco Europae. Book 1. 437–438.
29. Bordel, F. (1992). Materialis civilizationis, oeconomiae et capitalismi. Saeculis XV-XVIII [Material civilization, economy and capitalism. XVXVIII centuries:]: in 3 voluminibus. Moscow: Mysl, 1992. Volume 3. Vremya mira,. 680 p.
30. Kulisher, I. M., Essays de scientia nummaria [Essays on financial science]: In libro. Bibliography / author-compilers: S.I. Yuriy, S.V. Lyovochkin, V.M. Fedosov, P.I. Yukhymenko; scientiarum Ed. Fedosova K. (2010): Condor, In 3 vols. T. 3. Part 2. 2010. P. 255–257.
31. Bunge, N.H., (1869). Lege Vigilum [Police law:]: in 2 volumes Univ. typogr.. T. 1. 334 p.
32. Pikhno, D. I. (1899). Fundationes oeconomiae politicae []: K. : T-vo press. negotium et commercia I.N. Kushnereva and Co. (Kyiv branch), Issue 1. 167 p.
33. Davidis Riccardi opera [David Riccardo's works;]; trans. cum Anglis N. Zyber. St. Petersburg, 1882. 423 p.
34. Zyber, N. I. (1937). David Riccardo et Karl Marx in studiis socialibus et oeconomicis [David Riccardo and Karl Marx in their social and economic studies]. [1885]; ed. A. L. Raguel. M.:. 598 p.
35. Zyber, N. I. (1900). Economistae germanicae per oculos D. B. Chicherin [German economists through the eyes of Mr. B. Chicherin]. // Collectaeinfit: in 2 voluminibus St. Petersburg, T. 2. 778 p.
36. Kondratiev, M. D. (1925). Mikhail Ivanovich Tugan-Baranovsky [Mikhail Ivanovich Tugan-Baranovsky]. Pg.,. 127 p.
37. Tugan-Baranovsky, M. I. (1909). Fundamenta oeconomiae politicae [Fundamentals of political economy]. Petropoli: Typogr. acc. civitas "Verbum", 693 p.50
 38. Tugan-Baranovsky, M. I. (1894). Discrimina Industriae in moderna Anglia, earum causas et influxum in vita nationali [Industrial crises in modern England, their causes and influence on national life.]. St. Petersburg,. 207 p.;
39. Tugan-Baranovsky, M. I. discriminum Industrialium. Opusculum ex historia sociali Angliae. 2.
Recognitio. ed. St. Petersburg, 1900. 320 p.
40. Marshall, A. (1993). Principia scientiae [Principles of economic]. oeconomicae: in 3 volumes.
Progress. Volume 2. 414 p.
41. Zvainert, Y. (2007). Historia rerum oeconomicarum in Russia, 1805-1905 [History of economic thought in Russia, 1805-1905;]; trans. cum
German L. I. Tsedilyna; sub scientia ed. V. S. Autonomia. M.: Izd. Domus Civitatis Universitatis Superioris Educationis, 411 p.
42. Kharkiv Universitas nationalis nominatur a V. N. Karazin [Kharkiv National University named after V. N. Karazin]. url. www.univer.kharkov.ua: Nostra universitate
43. Tugan-Baranovsky, M. I. (1918). Socialismus pro scientia positive [Socialism as a positive science]. Pg. : Cooperator, 1918. 133 p.
44. Tugan-Baranovsky, M. I. Paper pecunia et metallo [Paper money and metal:]: In libro: Cogitatio pecuniaria Ucrainae. Bibliography / author-compilers: S.I. Yuriy, S.V. Lyovochkin, V.M. Fedosov, P.I. Yukhymenko (2010); scientiarum Ed. Fedosova K.: Condor, In 3 vols. T. 3. Part 2. P. 211–246.
45. Zvainert, Y. (2007). Historia rerum oeconomicarum in Russia, 1805-1905 [History of economic thought in Russia, 1805-1905;]; trans. cum German L. I. Tsedilyna; sub scientia ed. V. S. Autonomia. M.: Izd. Domus Civitatis Universitatis Superioris Educationis, 411 p.
46. Sobolev, M. N. (1919). Auxilia ad scholas cooperativas [Economic theory of cooperation] et cursus. Kh.: Soyuz, 196 p.
47. Sobolev, M. N. (1924). Organization of agricultural credit. Economy of Ukraine. No. 2. P. 3–11.
48. Sobolev, M. N. (1925). System of our money circulation and its completion // Economy of Ukraine.No. 3. P. 12–25.
49. Sobolev, M. N. (1925). Essays on financial science (publicly accessible). Kh.: Proletary, 186 p.
50. Sobolev, M. N. (1917). Age porro [Agrarian
question.]. insula literacy (Typ. . "Mane"), 1917. 16 p.
51. Yukhymenko, P. I., Lyovochkin, S. V., Fedosov, V. M., Yuri,y S. I. (2010). Sententia oeconomica Ucrainae [Financial opinion of Ukraine]. Monograph; scientiarum ed. V.,M. Fedosova K.: Condor, In 3 vols.
52. Kaufman, I. I. (1906). Pondus Russiae, eius progressus et origo in Sanctis cum historia systemata nummaria Russorum ab antique [Russian weight, its development and origin in the holidays with the history of Russian monetary systems since ancient times:]: Opyt issledovaniya. St. Petersburg,. 92 p.
53. Kaufman, I. I. (1909). Ex historia monetarum chartarum in Russia [From the history of paper money in Russia]. St. Petersburg : Typogr. "Septentrionalis", 292 p.
54. Kaufman, I. I. (1910). Argentum rublum in Russia ab origine sua usque ad finem saeculi XIX [Silver ruble in Russia from its origin to the end of the 19th century]. Petropoli: Typogr. B.V. Wolff, 268 p.
55. Myklashevsky, O. M. Pecunia. Experientia studiorum praecipua praescripta theoriae oeconomicae scholae classicae in nexu cum historia quaestionis monetariae [Money. The experience of studying the main provisions of the economic theory of the classical school in connection with the history of the monetary issue]: In libro: Cogitatio Financial de Ucraina.Bibliography / author-compilers: S.I. Yuriy, S.V. Lyovochkin, V.M. Fedosov, P.I. Yukhymenko (2010); scientiarum Ed. Fedosova K.: Condor, In 3 vols. T. 3.Part 1. 2010. P. 425–439.
56. Tugan-Baranovsky, M. I. Paper pecunia etmetallo: In libro: Cogitatio pecuniaria Ucrainae. Bibliography / author-compilers: S.I. Yuriy, S.V. Lyovochkin, V.M. Fedosov, P.I. Yukhymenko (2010Sententia oeconomica Ucrainae [Financial thought of Ukraine]; scientiarum Ed. Fedosova K.: Condor,In 3 vols. T. 3. Part 2. P. 211–246.
57. Bogolepov, M. I. (1916). I. Kaufman (obituarium) [I. Kaufman (obituary)]. Praeco Europae.Book 1. 437–438.
58. Friedman, M. (1998). Theoria quantitatis pecuniae: nova formula / Si nummi loquentes [Quantitative theory of money: new formulation / If the money started talking.;].; trans. cum Anglis — Moscoviae : Delo, 160 p.
59. Kaufman, I. I. (1873). Credit, ripae et pecuniae circulation [Credit, banks and money circulation].Petropoli: Typogr.-litogr. A.E. Landau, 1873. 928 p.
60. Shtein, V. M. (1948). Essays de evolution cogitationis socialis et oeconomicae Russiae saeculi XIX et XX [Essays on the development of Russiasocial and economic thought of the 19th and 20thcenturies]. L., 358 p.
61. Baranov, P. I. (1882). Mikhail Andreevich Baludyansky, Secretarius Status, Senator, Consiliarius privati (1769-1847) [Mikhail Andreevich Baludyansky, State Secretary, Senator, Privy Councilor
(1769-1847)]. Delineatio biographica. Petropoli: Typogr. Com.-va "Publicus Benefit", 92 p.
62. Yasnopolsky, L.N. (1913). Historica recensio
compositionis civitatis nostrae muralis et fiscalis reformationis [Essays on Russian budget law. 1. Historical review of the composition of our state murals and budget reform]. Tatarinov / L.N. Yasnopolsky — M. : Izdanie V. S. Ryabushinsky, 417 p.
63. Tverdokhlebov, V. N. (1916). infit Oeconomus [Financial essays]. Pg. Exitus 1. 168 p.
64. Tverdokhlebov, V. N. (1922). Oeconomicus limitis fiscalismi [Economic limit of fiscalism]. Renovationis oeconomicae. 1922. N. 2. P. 48–52.
65. Tverdokhlebov, V. N. (1945). Speransky eiusque activitatem in ambitu a rebus oeconomicis et pecuniae circulationem [Speransky and his activity in the area of finance and money circulation]. Soviet Pecuniae. N. 12. P. 3-17.
66. Kulisher, I. M. Essays de scientia nummaria [Essays on financial science]: In libro. Bibliogra51 econommeneg.btsau.edu.ua Економіка та управління АПК, 2024, № 2 phy / author-compilers: S.I. Yuriy, S.V. Lyovochkin, V.M. Fedosov, P.I. Yukhymenko; scientiarum Ed. Fedosova. Sententia oeconomica Ucrainae K.: Condor, 2010. In 3 vols. T. 3. Part 2. P. 255–257.
67. Sobolev, M. N. (1925). Essays on financial science (publicly accessible).. H.: Proletaiy. 149 p.
68. Tsytovych, N. (1889). Scientifica recension lucri entrepreneurialis [Scientific review of entrepreneurial profit.]. K.: Typogr. Imper. S. Vladimir University, 283 p.
69. Tsytovych, N. M. (1898). Locus expensarum Prussiae circa theoriam expensarum localium [Local expenses of Prussia in connection with the theory of local expenses.]. K.: Typogr. S. V. Kulzhenko, 735 p.
70. Tarasov, I. T. (2000). Docens circa societates iuncturas [Teaching about joint-stock companies;]; ed. numerus V.S. Em, D.V. Lomakin. M. : Statutum, 666 p.
71. Tarasov, I. T. Doctrina societatum iuncturarum []The doctrine of joint-stock companies:: In libro: Cogitatio pecuniaria Ucrainae. Bibliography / author-compilers: S.I. Yuriy, S.V. Lyovochkin,V.M. Fedosov, P.I. Yukhymenko (2010); scientiarumEd. Fedosova K.: Condor, In 3 vols. T. 3. Part 1. 2010.  P. 137–159.

 

AttachmentSize
PDF icon yukhymenko_31-51.pdf644.43 KB
ECONOMICS AND MANAGEMENT APC №2 2024